It is this kind of sovereignty popular sovereigntywhich is essential in the protection of other human rights. Issues like these were discussed in slaughter, annemarie, a liberal theory of international law 2000 94 american society of international law proceedings 240. Contemporary developments in the international protection of the rights of minorities. The right of selfdetermination is an attractive and popular concept. Article on the right to external self determination. These conflicts, framed in the rhetoric of selfdetermination, and the prospect and subsequently the reality of the dissolution of yugoslavia added to the perceived threat to the principle of territorial integrity. Special emphasis is placed on contemporary developments, but the journals range includes jurisprudence and legal history. Self determination, however, is enshrined in key human rights documents and by. Selfdetermination, relational autonomy, and transnational. The liechtenstein institute on selfdetermination at princeton university lisd and the permanent mission of liechtenstein to the united nations in new york convened a meeting in princeton in december 2018, in order to discuss the linkages between selfdetermination and conflict, in particular with regard to conflict prevention. While autonomy may respond to assertions for greater rights by an ethnic or. Great britain is a sovereign nation which may under certain circumstances be willing to grant more lo.
Nov 06, 2012 universal recognition of inalienable right to selfdetermination most effective way of guaranteeing fundamental freedoms, third committee told. But the inclusion of the right of self determination into international human rights law allows for a different approach to its interpretation. Hannums publications are international human rights. Pdf diplomacy and paradiplomacy in the redefinition of. The paper explores the nature of this conflict and. Creating a strategic framework for addressing the conflict. Jun 01, 2014 this article is an excerpt from eirs freetodownload edited collection, restoring indigenous self determination. Defining the right to selfgovernment when cracking open a thesaurus to find synonyms for freedom, one will undoubtedly come across the words autonomy and sovereignty. He died on january 31, 1987, of a heart attack, aged 43. Selfdetermination in conflict prevention and resolution. By hurst hannum autonomy, sovereignty, and self determination. Hurst hannum demands for autonomy or minority rights have given rise to conflicts, often violent, in every region of the world and under every political system. The accommodation of conflicting rights procedural aspects of international law hannum, hurst on.
Nov 01, 2001 right to self determination primarily concerns those under foreign occupation or colonialism, third committee told, as differing views are expressed. He was the brother of massoud barzani, the president of the krg, and the father of nechervan idris barzani. Theories of secession, philosophy and public affairs 10. Selfdetermination versus majority ruleequal rights. Demands for autonomy may therefore make it more difficult to identify the actual interests of the parties, such as linguistic or educational rights or a greater share in economic life. Hurst hannum autonomy, sovereignty, and selfdetermination. Council of minority rights group international london. Selfdetermination and sovereignty this article makes the normative case for a differentiated approach to the sovereignty. Indigenous selfdetermination and the legitimacy of sovereign. However, the right to self determination must be separated from the right to secession and the establishment of independent statehood, with. United nations audiovisual library of international law. The focus on idps in this handbook is not intended to. Second, the rights of the indigenous peoples will be examined from the perspective on international law, with special emphasis on the collective selfdetermination right. Autonomy, sovereignty, and selfdetermination hurst hannum.
The papua conflict is an ongoing conflict in western new guinea papua between indonesia and the free papua movement indonesian. By hurst hannum autonomy, sovereignty, and selfdetermination. Gillian triggs, the rights of peoples and individual rights. Professor hannum is the author or editor of numerous books and articles on international law and human rights, including international human rights.
Pdf the world over, agitations for selfdetermination, whether internal or external. Effective power is challenged by the principles of selfdetermination. Hurst hannum, autonomy, sovereignty and selfdetermination the accommodation of conflicting rights university of pennsylvania press, philadelphia, 1996. With the end of the cold war, ethnic conflict appears to be reemerging as subnational groups fight to be heard and represented. Autonomy, sovereignty, and selfdetermination the accommodation of conflicting rights. The themes discussed in the preceding chaptersnational unity and integrity, the right to selfdetermination, the human rights of minorities and indigenous peoples, sovereigntyhave been raised, often stridently, in each of the case studies which follow. Human rights, autonomy and national sovereignty michael dusche university of tubingen this paper1 examines the legal and ethical problems involved in reconciling two separate rights, each of which plays a fundamental role in the current philosophical debate surrounding international relations and international law. Problems of law, policy, and process, negotiating selfdetermination, guide to international human rights practice, and autonomy, sovereignty, and selfdetermination. The right to national selfdetermination within the eu. Read the fulltext online edition of autonomy, sovereignty, and self determination. The right to selfdetermination and its implication on the. Selfdetermination is defined as a right of nations to freely decide their sovereignty and political status without external compulsion or outside interference 2, p. These new concepts of self determination and sovereignty should help us move beyond the impasse between theories of nationalism and internationalism that has dominated international ethics now for a generation. In fact, the colonial context is what specifically comes to mind when the right to self determination is brought up and it is the colonial aspect of the right to self determination that is uncontested, for the right to self determination consists of many elements and it has several aspects.
South tyrol in italy did succeed in completely avoiding an escalation of violence in the 1960s. In order to explain the importance of sovereignty and self determination to young students, have them think back to lessons that focus on how biodiversity is good for the planet. The right to selfdetermination under international law. On this anniversary of 911 it is a good opportunity to compare spin and denial. Charter leaves selfdetermination ambiguous with one of its purposes stated in article 1. Autonomy, sovereignty, and selfdetermination the accommodation of conflicting rights hurst hannum. One of these means is the establishment of autonomy. Grazier professor of law and international relations american university president and cofounder, public international law and policy group house committee on foreign affairs.
Demands for autonomy or minority rights have given rise to conflicts, often violent, in every region of the world and under every political system. Request pdf selfdetermination and sovereignty over natural resources. Territorial integrity refers to the protection of an independent states territory from aggression of other states. An important feature of the journal is the case and comment section, in which members of the cambridge law faculty and other distinguished contributors analyse recent judicial decisions, new. Although it is difficult to find fault with the spirit ofthis notion, there is little agreement upon how self determination ought to be applied, and this disagreement over application brings to the. In africa, self determination emerged as a tool of struggle against colonialism. The project on state, sovereignty, and selfdetermination addresses issues of boundaries, identity, variants of autonomy, governance, selfdetermination, selfdeterminations potential devolutive and stateshattering capabilities, and the emerging version of selfdetermination as defining ones own destiny. Because selfdetermination encompasses so many issues including individual and minority rights, regional autonomy, government repression, territorial integrity, state sovereignty, and claims to independence, to name but a fewthe most difficult task in planning such a meeting was to determine which aspects of the issue would be addressed. Through an analysis of contemporary international legal norms and an examination of several specific case studiesincluding hong kong, india, the transnational problems of the kurds and saamis, nicaragua, northern ireland, spain, sri lanka, and.
Beyond this broad definition, however, no legal criteria determine which groups may legitimately claim this right in particular cases. Sovereignty, statehood, selfdetermination, and the issue of. The advantages result in particular from developing a concept of ecosovereignty out of a principle of popular self determination. In most cases, the minority group is a minority which has felt disadvantaged and discriminated against. This chapter explains why norms of self determination associated with nationalist preferences are likely to break down respect for norms of state sovereignty by potentially revisionist states within transborder dyads. An ever increasing number of peoples, groups, and even states and advocates on their behalf are wanting, demanding or fighting for their enjoyment of selfdetermination, with claims to a wide range of external and internal applications in the political, economic and cultural fields. Self determination betty miller unterberger the principle of self determination refers to the right of a people to determine its own political destiny. Selfdetermination of peoples and sovereignty over natural wealth and resources part two 97 firstly, in the 1950s, the debate on economic as well as political decolonization and, secondly, the controversy over developing countries economic progress by means of the exercise of their sovereign rights over natural resources. Pdf this article analyses the role of paradiplomacy in international security. Through an analysis of contemporary international legal norms and an examination of several specific case studiesincluding hong kong, india, the transnational problems. More precisely if less dramatically, of the hundreds of agreements, ceasefires and declarations which have been concluded between hostile parties since the second world war, relatively few of them have led to durable settlements.
It argues that conflictual bilateral relations will develop between states sharing a common national group due to the fact that. State, sovereignty, and selfdetermination liechtenstein. In his 1990 book autonomy, sovereignty, and selfdetermination the accommodation of conflicting rights, professor hannum has analyzed minority and indigenous rights, as well as a great number of regimes of autonomy, some of them successful while others have failed to ease tensions. If you feel the need, go ahead and check your thesaurus now. Self determination is the cardinal right sought by indigenous peoples and in practice it may require states to accept divisible sovereignty. Jx 4054 h34 1996 the selfdetermination of minorities in international politics.
The accommodation of conflicting rights university of pennsylvania press 1989 26. Read theories of secession, philosophy and public affairs on deepdyve, the largest online rental service for scholarly research with thousands of academic publications available at your fingertips. Autonomy the princeton encyclopedia of selfdetermination. The author has acted as an advisor or delegate in several of the settlement processes noted below. Sovereignty, territorial integrity and right of self. Autonomy, sovereignty, and self determination hurst hannum published by university of pennsylvania press hannum, hurst. Pavkovic explores how national selfdetermination, in the form of creation of a new state through secession, could override the principles of majority rule and of equal rights, which are primary liberal principles. Sovereignty, independence, selfdetermination 265 the report adopted by the committee examined particular residual links including the subordination of state parliaments to british legislation still applying as part of the law of the states, the role of british ministers in formal advice to the crown on state matters. Subsequent to the withdrawal of the dutch administration from the netherlands new guinea in 1962 and implementation of indonesian administration in 1963, the free papua movement has conducted a lowintensity guerrilla war against. Problems of law, policy, and practice aspen, 5 th ed. The resulting conditionality, however, raises sovereignty concerns as attempts to promote effectiveness may conflict with respect for recipient state sovereignty and indirectly violate individuals right to selfdetermination. Selfdetermination of peoples and sovereignty over natural. A territorial interpretation lea brilmayert the phrase selfdeterminationis simply loaded with dyna mite. The events of 911 are still being analysed, but dr judy woods collection of photographs reveal far more than the impact of two planes flying into the twin towers.
Autonomy, sovereignty, and selfdetermination by hurst hannum. Responding to claims for ethnic selfdetermination by hurst hannum hurst hannum is professor of international law at tufts universitys fletcher school of law and diplomacy and the author of autonomy, sovereignty, and selfdetermination. Selfdetermination, minority rights, and constitutional. Should a right to secession be conceded where all other means of protecting.
The importance of sovereignty and selfdetermination. Autonomy, sovereignty, and selfdetermination hurst hannum published by university of pennsylvania press hannum, hurst. For most states, self determination is framed by decolonization and is applicable to indigenous peoples only in limited senses of self government within state structures. In each of the nine situations, autonomy, selfgovernment, or selfdetermination is demanded by a group within an existing state, in order to protect the groupsculture. Traditionally, self determination was recognised as a right of peoples under colonial rule to gain independence. This includes the question of how an unwanted state can be imposed upon a.
India was among those countries which had insisted on adding recognition of right of all peoples to self determination to the international bill of human rights which the united nations adopted in 1976 to give a legal form to the rights set forth in the universal. Selfdetermination of indigenous peoples within the human. Selfdetermination in disputed colonial territories by jamie. His latest publications include settling selfdetermination conflicts 2007 with barbara metzger, and universal minority rights 2007.
The hardcover of the autonomy, sovereignty, and self determination. This concept of the right to selfdetermination seems to be the path leading to a more. Hannum, hurst, autonomy, sovereignty and selfdetermination. Creating a strategic framework for addressing the conflict between sovereignty and selfdetermination. While a sovereignty exercising state can be a totalitarian regime, it can also be a democratic one in which the sovereignty of the people confers and controls the sovereignty of the state. Define and discuss with the students the ideas of sovereignty and self determination. University of pennsylvania press, 1996 law 534 pages.
The cambridge law journal publishes articles on all aspects of law. In response, autonomy was rediscovered as a potential remedy to selfdetermination claims kymlicka 2007. The tension between the right to external selfdetermination. It has become common in recent years, however, for autonomy and sovereignty to be distinguished in political discourse. Self determination in disputed colonial territories takes a contextual, historical approach to mapping the existing law and will be of interest to international lawyers, as well as scholars of international relations and students of the history of decolonization. The accommodation of conflicting rights philadelphia. In each of the nine situations, autonomy, selfgovernment, or selfdetermination is demanded by a group within an existing state, in order to protect the groups culture.
602 696 1426 1041 1200 780 828 505 735 1343 280 734 1132 1292 943 642 644 1269 1429 754 266 1090 899 500 576 954 516 63 149 755 508 168 516 1075 127 652 377 429 956